APS TechNotes See all articles

Should you repair or replace your water softener or carbon system?

Should you repair or replace you water softener?

We get this question often and think it is a good one.

Replace vs repair is a balancing act for sure.

If the water softener is less than 5 years old it is most likely under warranty and is usually worth repairing.

If your softener is over 10 years old, you will find it is far easier and usually cheaper to replace it. 

If it is under warranty, go to who you got it from for repair. If they are out of business, you are probably on your own.  

  • A new softener is about $500.00-600.00 Delivered.
  • A new head is about $300.00 Delivered
  • New Resin is about $130.00 Delivered.
  • A new salt tank is about $150.00 Delivered

    That being said, I find if you have to fix one thing, you will have to fix all things soon after since they tend to wear out at the same time.

    For myself, I would rather fix it once and do more important things in life. A new softener will give you many years without problem as long as you use pellet salt (99.5% pure) and a automatic resin cleaner.  

    You have to decide how much you are willing to invest in it or if you should just replace the softener. If you are lucky, you may be able to get off cheap without a lot of hassle. If you are like me, it will cost more to keep fixing it then it is to replace it.  

    Here are some links to some info that may help you.

  • Water Softener Diagram
  • Water Softener Installation Instructions
  • About hard water and softening
  • Tips on selecting a softener
  • Water Softener Sizing Calculator
  • How to change resin in  a water softener
  • What Size and Capacity is your water softener

  • Call Us Anytime

    We Offer Over 28,000 Products
    Should you repair or replace your water softener or carbon system?
    Purchase Orders Accepted
    (subject to approval)
    Credit Application

    Rated "A+" with the BBB
    25 years, Zero Complaints

    Got a Millipore Water System?
    For Huge Savings
    Click Here
    Best ...

    Shower Filters
    Reduces chlorine
    and other contaminents

    New Feature
    Lab Water Filter Database

    Millipore Filter Quick List
    Barnstead Filter Quick List

    Barnstead Micropure - Should you repair or replace your water softener or carbon system?
    ... No Description... ... List All Products

    Best Best Best Carbon Filter

    Images may or may not be of actual product.

    * Flat Rate UPS shipping when able to ship via UPS and is in the USA excluding Hawaii and Alaska.
    Larger Items may not be able to ship via UPS, in that case freight charges will be quoted seperately.

    8/25/2016 at 6:08:24 AM
    Terms and conditions
    Credit Application

    Privacy Policy

    Tags :

    Should you repair or replace your water softener or carbon system?
    Clack is a registered trademark of Clack corporation

    Barnstead Water Filtration Products
    Laboratory Water Products